by Kathy Bence
Photo courtesy of Barbara Klein taken from Wire Mesa
Town Hall & City Council
Lots of Solara
There was plenty of city action on November 18, 2026, beginning with a Town Hall meeting and followed by the City Council meeting.
The major topic of interest was, of course, the annexation of property involving Solara. Spoiler alert: the vote was 4–1 in favor of annexation, with Wayne Olsen casting the only opposing vote. Brian McNary shared his thoughts on the decision in this post.
The Solara discussion kicked off the Town Hall meeting, which you can watch here. The public hearing on Solara at the start of the City Council meeting begins here.
I do not claim to be an objective journalist, so if you want to hear exactly what was said and draw your own conclusions, I encourage you to watch the videos.
During the meetings, several residents shared their concerns about Solara's connection to an ongoing Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceeding. Notably, Michelle Peot, who has researched and written about this topic, shared her concerns and provided background on the property. She introduced herself as a Leeds resident who lives closer to the proposed Solara development than any Toquerville resident.
The mayor and some council members assured residents that the bankruptcy would have no financial impact on Toquerville. They pointed to PIDs (Public Infrastructure Districts) as a means of protecting the city from financial risk.
Sarah Anderson had a different take. She is the St. George resident who voiced concerns about this annexation while running for a County Commission seat.
She said that while it might be legally true to say the developer's bankruptcy case costs Toquerville nothing, that did not mean there was no cost to the community.
“A PID doesn't remove risk. It moves it... onto the families who buy those homes. Completion bonds ARE required, phase by phase… a bond protects one phase. Not the whole project. In April, the developer said that if the market falls flat, they'll phase the project and its PIDs. That protects the developer. What protects everyone else?”
Lynda Williams asked whether the completed development would contain 1,500 residential units. The response suggested that the mix of single-family and multifamily housing would depend on market conditions, up to the maximum number of units allowed. In other words, the developer has flexibility in how the project is built and phased.
After hearing from the city that no one had filed a protest, Mike Franzen pointed out that Toquerville residents were not automatically eligible to file a formal statutory protest against the annexation. State law limits who may file such protests, and simply being a city resident does not qualify someone. He also questioned the density and the percentage of units that could be used as nightly rentals.
The Mayor read an email from Dave Esquer, who expressed concerns and pointed to numerous red flags that, in his view, warranted further investigation and at least a postponement of the annexation decision.
Following the comments, the Council discussed the subject further. Overall, council members supporting the annexation argued that Toquerville would be better off having jurisdiction over the property rather than leaving its future development outside city boundaries. They believe annexation is in the best interest of the city. That was the recurring theme of both meetings.
No one who spoke during the public hearing expressed support for the annexation. Nevertheless, the Council voted 4–1 to approve it.
The irony did not escape me that residents had been encouraged to attend these meetings so their voices could be heard. They were heard. Whether their concerns influenced the outcome is another question.
Other Comments
During the Town Hall meeting, the Rocky Mountain Power Three Peaks power line project was brought up, along with the tree on Mountain Charm Road.
During the public comments, Lynn Williams asked if a date had been set for turning the bypass road over to the state. The Mayor said no date had been set because not all of the property needed for the bypass had been secured. That raises an interesting question: How was the road built on property the city had not yet secured?
Mike Franzen asked when signs restricting the use of engine brakes would be installed on the bypass. He said he had recorded noise levels as high as 83 decibels, compared with what he identified as a residential limit of 66 decibels.
Manny Butterworth commented that residents would appreciate—and be relieved—if developers were required to comply with applicable ordinances and agreements. He asked the council to make every effort to ensure developers are held accountable.
And Sarah Anderson, speaking as someone from outside Toquerville, complimented the council on how open the meetings were. Although comments from audience members' seats are not normally encouraged, attendees were allowed to speak from their seats during both meetings.
Non-Solara Business Items
Give it back
An ordinance declaring real property identified as Parcel W-227-E surplus and authorizing its conveyance to the original donor.
This was an unusual business item. Someone had donated Washington County property to the city and now wanted it back. Unlike Solara, no one had a comment during this public hearing. They voted to give it back to the original owner.
Standing up to Developers?
An ordinance approving a material modification to the Firelight MPDO Plan and Development Agreement regarding a development-wide signage plan and authorizing the Mayor to execute the addendum.
To start off this fascinating discussion, the Mayor jokingly pointed out that Firelight had asked to be moved up on the agenda, but he had stood up to the developer and made its representatives sit through the entire meeting.
Firelight was requesting approval for signs larger than those permitted under the city's current code. Ironically, this request followed Manny's earlier comment urging the council to require developers to follow city rules. Firelight was seeking an exception to the city's sign requirements so its signs could be more visible from the parkway and help attract buyers.
Joey Campbell asked Firelight representative Steven Wood to respond to concerns raised earlier by residents that developers' interests sometimes take precedence over those of Toquerville residents.
The Mayor then questioned why Firelight couldn't simply comply with the city's existing sign requirements. He also asked how allowing larger signs would benefit residents.
Wayne Olsen and other council members questioned what precedent granting this exception might set for future developers.
Steven Wood had to leave before the discussion concluded, so the council voted to table the matter.
At this point, city attorney Lisa Watts Baskin, who was introduced November 4 as Toquerville's new attorney, offered an explanation of how development agreements operate. She said:
“It's been said a couple times tonight that we're side stepping the ordinances or ignoring the law with these development agreements. What in fact you're doing is you're enacting an ordinance when you approve the development agreement unique to the project.”
In other words, she explained that approving a development agreement involves enacting an ordinance specific to that project, rather than simply disregarding existing law.
However these changes are accomplished, it is clear that residents want their interests considered alongside those of developers. After all, unlike developers who may eventually move on to other projects, residents remain in the community and live with the long-term consequences.
Signs matter, but they are small potatoes compared with other land-use decisions. Let me share a larger example that I mentioned during the Solara annexation public hearing:
“Last year, I attended the meeting where the City Council rezoned the Devil's Hole property. It went from allowing one home per 20 acres to a theoretical maximum of 43 homes on those same 20 acres. I was surprised by how easily the City Council approved that change.”
Property rights are sometimes mentioned when developers seek increased residential density. But zoning determines what property owners are allowed to do, and the City Council has considerable authority when it comes to changing those rules.
Perhaps we should give decisions about residential density at least as much scrutiny as we give decisions about signs.
On to Babylon
A Hillside Development Permit application submitted by Babylon Lands, LLC for Iconic Parkway.
From my limited understanding of this discussion, the issue involved the proposed Iconic Parkway road and whether its construction would comply with the city's hillside ordinance. The debate centered on how much cutting into the hillside would be necessary to build this residential road while meeting city requirements. The road is trying to avoid Devil's Hole area and involves BLM land.
Jeff Thomas of American Consulting and Engineering explained that some areas of steeper slopes overlap but are not contiguous, and that most of the proposed road would not pass through areas with slopes of 30% or greater.
Wayne Olsen expressed concern about the extent of the cuts into the hillside, but the two city engineers indicated that the proposal complied with the city's hillside ordinance.
The Council approved the application.
work items
Transportation Master Plan
Darrin LaFevre, Assistant City Manager, spoke about the Transportation Master Plan. This plan will play an important role in future transportation decisions. Todd Sands asked whether the decibel levels mentioned earlier in the meeting were being considered as part of the Master Plan. Apparently, they are not.
blasting permits
The Mayor said the city is not required to be notified before blasting takes place. The fire district oversees blasting permits, but the city has been receiving numerous complaints.
He said blasting associated with a future subdivision is expected to continue for approximately three months, generally between 2 and 4 p.m. He warned residents to stay away from the area during blasting.
The city attorney recommended sending a letter requesting that the city receive advance notification of scheduled blasting.
calendar
Christmas Tree Lighting – Monday, November 30th at 7:00 p.m. at the Toquerville City Hall
Winter Community Clean-up – Saturday & Sunday, December 5th and 6th. Dumpsters at TRE Park, Center Street Park, Westfield Park and Toquerville Heights (Rim View Drive near the mailboxes).
Wreaths Accross America — Saturday, December 19